When I first started using this mascara it was great and made my lashes big and full. But it dried out quickly. So sad.

This product is very hard to remove once it is applied. I am not happy with my purchase.

I have tried for tubes of this mascara thinking maybe I was doing something wrong. I was excited when I opened the first two and saw the brush. I thought grades this brush will really be clean with no plans. I was wrong after only a little over a week using at the mascara clumps on the brush like crazy. My lashes are a mess. It gets all over my eye lids. I do not recommend it and will not buy it again.

I'm on a borderline with this mascara.at the start if the day this mascara is amazing it gives my lashes alot if volume.but after a long day of work this mascara flakes off.

This is the only waterproof mascara that I will use, because it is so good. I have worn it all day at the beach or water park and it doesn't budge. I love the look that it gives my lashes and isn't hard to remove at the end of the day.

I typically hate waterproof, but this is the best waterproof mascara I have tried. Helps lashes hold a curl.

This gives some volume but mainly lengthens your lashes, but it separates greatly so lashes don't look clumpy.

Love this mascara! Really adds volume and length to my lashes and the formula doesn't weigh my lashes down.

This product is HORRIBLE. I'm sorry, "waterproof" doesn't mean glued to your lashes even when you use makeup remover, soap, ANYTHING to try and get it off. If removing it isn't nightmarish enough, it doesn't even look good going on. Horribly clumpy, feels sticky and awful while on. This was by far the worst mascara I've ever tried and I've tried many different products. I like several of L'Oreals other mascaras, one of which is waterproof, stays on but slides off easily with makeup remover. They desperately need to fix this one or take it off the shelves. If I still had my receipt and the box I'd take this back for a refund, instead just going to toss it, not worth even tolerating. So disappointed. (ps. some of my lashes CAME OUT trying to remove this mascara).

Great value, very effective. Good coverage, not messy, does not flake. Does take a little work to remove since it is waterproof. I use after curling and lashes stay curled with this mascara.

I have oily skin and oily eyelids by mid day. I don't like a lot of makeup "prep" therefore I don't use eye primer. This mascara lasts all day long and keeps my curled (I use an eyelash curler) eyelashes upright. Other mascaras look great for a few hours but this one keeps my lashes looking great ALL day long. I purchased the waterproof formula and remove it easily with baby oil. Love it!!!

Just literally bought this the other day & have to say that it wasn't bad. I'm not crazy about the brush but I can look past that. I would buy again but it wouldn't be the first one I'd gravitate towards. I also love how waterproof this is but I'm giving it 4 stars because I really like the volume & the packaging is super nice also.

I'd been looking for a new waterproof mascara because my favorite had been discontinued. I had tried several other brands and was not satisfied. But then L'Oreal caught my attention with the gold packaging and the "blue voluminous strip" info. AND Bam! I saw the waterproof logo on the packaging... Bought it, tried it, loved it!!! (This was my first time using a L'Oreal product.) I loved it so much I bought it for my mom, she loved it too :D I go to aquatics exercise classes, swim laps and it stays on. Last Sunday, cried my eyes out at the movies, it DID NOT flake or smudge! This mascara has made it through it all! I've left it on til' the next day and it's looked great. I do use another brand of make up remover to take it off though. The L'Oreal brand didn't work for me :( don't know why... I must confess I tried two other mascara brands and came back to my "L'Oreal Voluminous Million Lashes." I use it everyday too. When I want a more dramatic look, I use "Voluminous False Fiber Lashes" (also waterproof) over "Voluminous Million Lashes." But then it doesn't last as long. Overall, I am very pleased with L'Oreal! I have also started using L'Oreal Visible Lift Serum Absolute Foundation SPF 17 and really liked it. Definitely recommend their products and I don't have to pay an arm and a leg for them!

it's been a long time since i've had loreal mascara... found a tube of the waterproof blackestblack.. and OMG, HOLY MILLIONS OF LASHES! definate sepereation... may need to wipe off extra mascara bafore using brush, but it worked great! the brush is totally what makes it!

This is my ultimate favorite mascara! I have long thick lashes and Voluminous Million Lashes Waterproof Mascara is the only mascara that will keep my lashes up and looking flawless!!!

I was looking for a mascara that truly made my lashes look fuller and longer. This is IT! The brush really does separate and coat each lash

I love this mascara. It blows covergirl and maybelline out of the water. The applicator is perfect and the dark black color is amazing. I've gotton so many compliments on how my eyes popped when i wore this mascara! I will continue to buy this product! Well done, L'Oreal!

I tried this for a change from my usual voluminous original which I love. Although I liked the coverage, I did not like the wand applicator.

I have super straight lashes that are invisible if not curled. I like that this keeps them curled, is very black and volumizes. I would rate it 5 stars if it were easier to remove. Nearly impossible to completely remove from lashes without torturing my eyes... even using the loreal waterproof eyemakeup remover.