I absolutely love this eyeliner from loreal. The brown sade is a perfect chocolate color that appears brown not black. Its perfect for me as someone with fair skin and blonde/red eyebrows and lashes. It looks more natural and warm versus black. I'd love to find a waterproof version. But over all its very nice!

I love the eyeliner, the color is great and pigmented. It last for hours for me, and love the color with my makeup. Overall I highly recommend it!!!!

I love this rich brown shade, it’s very easy to apply and I had no issues with it staying in my water line and it’s also very comfortable to wear, I also like to use it as a lipliner so it’s a 2 for 1 for me.

L’Oreal Paris Eyeliner it’s very easy to put on. It has no scent. Easy to sharpen. The brown leather color is unique. You can buy this one at CVS or Walgreens.

This eyeliner is mixed it with black snd give me a nice brighter brown black mix. I lobe how easy it is for application and the wear was lasting. it clearly dried fast. It made me feel cuter!

The best liquid liner I have tried. I loved the brim so much I went to the store and got one in black too!! It’s super easy to apply and it lasts all night. Pretty color too!!

I was really impressed with this eyeliner pencil. It glides on pretty smoothly and is smudge able when first applied for a smokier look but won’t budge once it is set. I love the brown leather shade. It is a gorgeous, dark, cool toned brown. It makes my greenish blue eyes pop.

I couldn’t find the package with this eyeliner when it was delivered, but never heard back from Influenster. I wanted to complete my task and not lie about it, so my SIL and I picked this up at CVS. I hope I got the right one. It’s a pretty standard pencil eyeliner, which I way prefer to liquid. My favorite thing is the application, as it does glide on really well, which is the main reason I skip eyeliner - it’s just not smooth the way I want it to be going on. Easy to use, and good color transfer even over shadow. I didn’t notice any flaking or smudging above what I would call normal, but I do tend to mess up my makeup when my eyes water or itch and I forget to mind my makeup when dealing with it. Which is to say, I did have some flaking, but I think that was mainly from mascara as it’s not unique to when I wore this eyeliner. Sadly, can’t do a pic because I left it with my SIL after testing. She is a daily liner user, whereas I tend to be more of an event user, so it made sense to leave it with her. I would definitely recommend to those looking for a smooth gliding eye pencil.