Good idea but very difficult to hold the removable stencil at exactly the same angle on both side. I ended up with non-symmetrical cat eyes. They are perfect cat eyes but one side is higher than the other. Is there a trick of how to line up the stencil when getting ready to do the other eye?

Loved it at first but on my fourth time using it the eyeliner was leaking from the tip and dropped all over everything. And now it’s dried out and I only had it for a week

I love it, very pigmented and the stencil is a great help because I’m horrible at doing my makeup, but I feel like I’m going to remove my eyelids trying to remove it even using coconut oil which I use for the rest of my makeup.

I am not a fan of liquid eyeliner by no means but I assume where the lid has the 'cheater guide' as I call it, I am now a fan!

First of all, I don't wear eyeliner often. And when I do, it's definitely not "cat eye" because that's the hardest to master, in my opinion. This was very easy to use and apply. The stencil lid is insanely helpful to make sure you get the perfect angles. The liquid applies seamlessly and is easy to quickly remove before it dries *if* you make a mistake.

This product is awesome. It's easy to apply. Doesn't smear. The removable wing stencil is easy to access and put up so it doesn't get lost. I would recommend this to all my friends and family.

This pen definently needed someshakes but it wasthen dark and completely water proof, even under a faucet. It removed easily with a makeup wipe

With the stencil given with the eyeliner its so easy to draw cat eyes without messing it up. Good quality eyeliner glides on smoothly and is long lasting.

I love makeup and I've been wearing it since I was a little girl because I grew up dancing competitively, but I've never been able to master a bold cat eye. L'Oreal's Infallible Flash Cat Eye liquid liner makes the process a breeze. The liner's tip is firm and pointed, making it easy to get liner exactly where you need it to go. It's extremely pigmented, so you don't need to go over your line multiple times, and is waterproof enough to wear all day in the hot summer without smudging or fading. The best part about it, however, is the tool attached to the lid. You can line it up at the corner of your eye to trace a perfect cat eye without worrying about shaky hands or crooked lines. I must warn that it make take a few tries to learn where to place the tool, but once you get the hang of it, you'll be drawing perfect cat eyes in seconds.

I love this liner, it is one of the few liquid liners that you can apply like a pen and it actually works well! Just enough liquid comes out as you use it and the felt tip is very thin making it easy to apply. The stencil is great but it does take some time to get used to it before it comes out exactly like you want so I would suggest trying out several times before actually using it for a glam look.

Very good affordable eyeliner. I rubbed my eyes a few times and it didnt wipe off or smear. I didnt use the cat eye stencil because I've been doing my eyes winged for years and have it down but i love that this is a waterproof liner. Goes on smoothly and evenly. Very good pigment.

I really enjoyed the look and the feel of the pen. I thought it was an unique design concept to include the stencil in the cap. When I removed the stencil off of the pen, I noticed the stencil was a little flimsy and hard to hold..to me it was not as easy to figure out without reading the instructions on the package. The eyeliner glided on the skin without smudging very nicely but I did not feel as if the stencil did what it was supposed to do. I did one eye with the stencil and did not like how it looled so using the pen I did the other eye freehand as I normally do and perfected my Free hand results better. Overall the liner held up very good. No smuging or fading so I would certainly buy this brand of liquid liner but not positive I would utilize the stencil. I will try the stencil again because maybe it's just a learning curve.