Like the idea of a coating before applying mascara. Only wish the mascara brush was a comb on one side and a brush on the other side to spread the lashes while coating them so they don't clump.

I have very sensitive eyes and I wear contact lenses, and this mascara is by far the best product I have bought. Aside from the mascara being waterproof with no smears, it also separates and coats my individual lashes beautifully.

First off, I don't like this type of mascara to begin with and this one reaffirmed that. The 2 step process just makes your final look more clumpy and caked-on looking without the extension effect. I find it messier than a regular mascara and it doesn't seem to last as long.

I bought this mascara a few days ago. I normally use a different primer mascara that Loreal makes. I don't like this Voluminous version. It is sticky and very very hard to remove. My lashes do not look as long or thick as my normal mascara. I will not buy this again.

Is perfect for now the summer, very good waterproof mask.

I tried it today. I put this wp over L’Oreal butterfly sculpt and it’s the best mascara I’ve had.

I had a coupon for this, so i decided to check it out. So glad i did. The undercoat really helps extend my somewhat disappearing lashes. Love this...so glad I tried

LOVE this mascara. I have hyper oily skin and eyeliners, shadows and mascaras tend to slide off my eyes to my under-eye area after half a day. This stuff stays in place all day and washes off easily. The 2 steps isn't a problem, either. Please don't ever discontinue this!

I bought this a month ago and and itmakes my lashes look very bold.

I really like the idea of a product that enables a person to go from day to night and this is one. I am fair skinned with blond eyelashes and it makes a huge difference in my appearance for the better to focus on my eyelashes more than any other feature. I would love to see this expanded to include waterproof eye shadow on the otherside with some sparkle that could be added to the eye, cheek or lips as well to really rocket this product into the stratosphere!

Exactly what I wanted and needed. I really like it !!!

Great Mascara, to add volume and extend lashes to great extent.

I love this product and buy it all the time. I love the way it looks.

L'Oreal if you see this review please please make the mascara version on its own. let me tell you guys the mascara on the end of this is such a great formula I really never tried anything like it before the curve of the wand seems to hold my curl all day long and a lot of mascaras don't hold up to that claim the formula on the black side is absolutely amazing there's no transfer it stays put all day I really would like to have a full size of this I've had this for over a year and it's still going strong and I use mascara every single day. now the reason I gave it 4 stars is due to the primer side now I've used it with this mascara and I've used it with other mascaras and I just don't think it's a wow product I definitely think like I said they could do without the primer and just made the mascara larger size any tips that I can give for the primer side is apply it and then go through and use a spoolie to kind of thin it out because there's a lot of product that does buildup on the brush but I DO think that it does give your lashes a more volumised look I'm not into the clumpy/thick look. Again speaking on the prime not mascara . I like my lashes to be very separated and long but when I'm looking for volume it is a great go to I don't notice that the primer makes it last any longer but I do like the product overall please L'Oreal make this mascara and a bigger version I think it's so great and keep the wand because it's amazing

I tried this mascara after reading several good reviews about it on a blog. However, it wasn't for me. The mascara did not go on smoothly after applying the primer. It was clumpy and sticky and smeared.

Worst mascara I've ever used. It's clumpy, dry and next to impossible to remove. I tried micellar water, coconut oil, baby wipes, soap EVERYTHING. when I did eventually get the majority of it off my eyelashes came with it.

this is by far the best mascara I've ever used. Gives a dramatic effect and really makes my eyelashes look super long. The but.....it's impossible to remove the waterproof version (usually buy the non-waterproof but bought this by mistake). Will be buying the other asap before I rip my lashes out trying to get this off. I still recommend this product though, amazing lashes!

I buy this mascara exclusively and absolutely love it. Waterproof but easy to remove. I get a lot of compliments on my eyes and some folks have asked if I'm wearing false eyelashes.

I don't normally post reviews but this mascara was a total waste of $ for me. The primer made my lashes clump together and the mascara only worsened the effect. It was not a good look at all. The positive is that the formula is indeed waterproof/long-lasting....so much so that I still had lots of residual mascara after using eye make-up remover. I had to continuously scrub away at my lashes to remove it, which is probably not good for the sensitive eye area or my lashes. I tried it on twice and both times were a disaster. I'm going back to my regular Voluminous False Fiber Waterproof. Glad to see that it works for some people though.

I've bought this mascara several times. I love that it's water proof. Love the primer and how the black goes over it and I can layer it. It does not smudge when dry. It's great for my athletic sweaty lifestyle!! Great product and I recommend it to everyone.

Just purchased this mascara and it is not worth a penny to buy, don't waste your money. It defiantly does not go on smooth and does nothing for your lashes. Had to go over it with another mascara to make it better. Not worth the money at all. Do not buy

I bought this about two weeks ago and just tried to use it. It was like it was old. I used to use the old version all the time and loved it but it seems they have changed the formula. I had to keep going over and over my lashes to get some mascara on them. Wasn't a nice effect so had to wash my eye makeup off and start all over with a different product. Tried to return it but had already thrown out receipt.